More heart than brain.

Royalty free image compliments of Microsoft Office

Royalty free image compliments of Microsoft Office

As I’ve previously shared, my older daughter, C, started classes at the nearby community college last fall, a decision that was all hers. She made the decision the summer in advance of her senior year while bouncing around the hills of Mongolia. Despite varied options and a persuasive visit from a college recruiter during her senior year, she followed her heart and showed great maturity when she decided community college would ease the transition from homeschooler to college student.

We hadn’t taken the increasingly popular road of  ”concurrent enrollment”, starting college classes during the high school years. For her senior year, she decided to stay the course with me and the “one day” school she had participated in on and off for years and  leave the college coursework for her college years. On occasion, she voiced her doubts; “Am I going to end up behind? All my friends are already taking college classes. What if I can’t get a good job because they’re all taken by the time I get out?”

“No need to rush,” I reassured her. “You’ve shown me you know how to make good decisions. Trust your gut and enjoy your senior year. Coast a little, you’ve earned it.” (Not that she ever  really coasted; I don’t think she knows how.)

Nonetheless, I was not-so secretly pleased when I heard I’d get a front row seat to watch her launch into the next chapter (even if wasn’t her motivation for staying local.)  I would share another year with my first-born; a decision that, despite her demonstrated ability to make good choices, brought relief. But, not for the predictable and often anticipated fears like drinking, drugs, and other stupid  common, regretful mistakes of  youth. As the woman who felt solely responsible for her schooling, I claimed any gaps in her education as mine. No one else’s. Mine. And, if gaps appeared in her study skills, essay abilities, or world history, I’d need be there to fill them while she was still under my roof. (Have I mentioned my melodramatic side before?)

As much as I wish we had another 5 years to cover all the literature I’d wanted to share, I’ve accepted she’s no longer my student. As much as I wish I could go back and undo some of the pitfalls of my homeschooling (like not pushing her harder in math, despite her natural tendencies toward an English major), she’s no longer my student. As much as I wish she had experienced more “classroom competition”, she’s no longer my student and these things cannot be undone. On some level, I anticipated these regrets. I knew there would be a long list of books left unread and a “hindsight awareness” of mistakes I made during our 12 years of homeschooling together. But, wishes don’t turn back the clock, so I focused my eyes forward.

Last summer flew by but by the time fall arrived I thought we were ready for this year. I thought my research about the college years and the transition to the “empty nest years” had prepared me. Though not without its bumps, I thought our relationship was solid and secure. I thought her demonstrated maturity had prepared me to allow her to transition to next step with ease and grace. I thought.

Perhaps, I thought too much…or not enough. Honestly, it’s been a bumpier transition than I had anticipated. One day I’m her mom and her teacher, doling out chores and curfews along with essays, literature lists, and science assignments. The next I’m just mom, writing a tuition check and failing (miserably) at keeping my mouth shut. I’m certain there’s less turbulence found in the airspace over the Rocky Mountains than in my kitchen of late. Little did I know I should have installed a “fasten seatbelt” sign before her first semester’s registration was complete.

I lived at home while attending the local university. (In those days, there were no requirements about living on campus the first year of school as is popular among schools today.) I either took the bus or carpooled with one of my siblings every day. I waited tables to pay for my tuition and books while abiding by the house rule of “free room and board so long as I was a serious student”, meaning C’s or better, with an emphasis on the “better”. My father reviewed my grades every semester. He counseled me on class selections, helped me develop my writing skills by reviewing my papers, and guided me back on track when my grades slipped. He also gave each of his children the same advice: “For every hour in class, you should study two hours outside of class.” Secretly, my siblings and I mocked and bemoaned his directive. Many years passed before any of us garnered the courage to tease him about the unrealistic “math” of that equation, especially since most of us took 15-18 units per semester while working to pay for our educations!  Above all, he was well-intentioned, wanting to help each of us to succeed. And in the way most parents help, my parents regularly offered the (often hard knocks) wisdom they had gathered along life’s journey. Advice that was not always welcomed.

It’s taken a bit of memory jarring, usually provided by my sister, but I now recall how I often rebelled and rejected my parents’ offerings of wisdom and help. Their rules and guidance felt restrictive and antiquated when I thought I was “old enough to make all my own decisions.” I wasn’t a bad kid, but spirited I was and, like most teens, I often chomped at the bit for the “freedoms” I thought came upon high school graduation. Then reality hit. There were two roads ahead: school (read: work and responsibility) or work (read: work and responsibility). Those were the “freedoms” granted me upon graduation because lounging on the couch doing nothing wasn’t an option. Nor is it for my children.

Those are hard to swallow responsibilities ”freedoms” when you’re barely an adult,  just out of high school and convinced the college themed movies are what life will look like. Rarely, does life imitate the movies, for student or parent.

Now, almost a year out of high school, I know those responsibilities can still feel hard for C to swallow. But, as a parent, it’s my job to raise a responsible adult, not enable a couch potato.

Truth is, C’s a hard worker, independent of my nagging. She made “Dean’s List” her first semester and was invited into an honor’s society.  She’s carried a heavier load this semester and she’s on track to pull out equally good grades. She’s a good student. She’s conscientious and self-disciplined. Most of the time. After all, at only 19, she’s still young.

Another truth is, I’ve nagged. A lot. More than I should’ve. More than I’ve needed to. It can be hard to keep my mouth shut when I think she’s not studying enough, or staying up too late, or…. and it’s caused a lot of turbulence around here. More often than not, it’s ”mama fear” stemmed from irrational worries. But, it’s also “mama love” in the same way my father loved me when he spent hours pouring over a course catalog helping me select classes. I hated it then; I value it now. He helped me prepare for life, and he prepared me to help my daughters. Perhaps one day, my daughters will feel the same.

C will be going away next year. She’ll be attending the school that recruited her, her top pick, and the only one she was interested in leaving home for. It’s a small, private, all women’s college. She’ll be 12 hours away. She’ll not have me peeking in on her at night to see if she’s studying or wasting time texting with a friend. She’ll stay out late, eat more junk food than she should, cram for a test at the last minute, make friends that lift her up when she falls, and discover new depths to her strength. She’ll come home to visit at Thanksgiving and Christmas, but spend spring break abroad, not at home.  All life experiences that’ll be good for her. And me.

She’s ready for this next transition. And I am, too.

Almost.

I think.

That’s the thing about transitions. You can read and research and ask all the mentors you can find but still flounder when the time comes because you can’t fully prepare the heart. A heart doesn’t respond like a brain. It doesn’t think about her maturity and proven decision making.  It thinks about the baby you once held, and the little girl who cried over a lost friend, the joy over a first date, or the last glance as she walked through airport security that first time alone.

The thing I’ve learned about transitions this year is that, despite preparations, there’s more heart than brain involved when you open your hands and say “Fly”, and they do.

When was the last time you experienced more heart than brain, and how did you handle it?

Posted in Transitional Parenting | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Honey, it’s your decision. (Kind of. Sort of. Maybe.)

Image courtesy of Microsoft Office

Image courtesy of Microsoft Office

“Mommy, can dolly come too?”

“Honey, it’s your decision…but, just know I’m not going to carry her and you don’t want to lose her.”

(It’s your decision, but I’ve let you know my opinion; don’t bring her.)

“Mom, should I wear my red sweater or the blue one?”

“Honey, it’s your decision…but didn’t the red one have a stain? The blue one looks nice with those pants.”

(And since we are going out in public, I don’t want you wearing something that has a stain on it. What would other people think?)

“Mom, I’m going shopping with a friend, do you think it’s OK to take some money from savings?”

“Honey, it’s your decision…but don’t forget you have some bills coming due and you don’t want to start that bad habit.”

(So, NO, don’t move any (of YOUR) money out of savings! Really, you even had to ask?)

I can’t count the number of times I’ve said, “Honey, it’s your decision” over the last (almost) 19 years. I’ve tried to raise empowered daughters that felt they could come to me for guidance and wisdom but also knew that, ultimately, their decisions were/are theirs. I always wanted them to be both comfortable in making decisions and in taking responsibility for them. But, it all began long ago, when they were so, so… malleable. My manipulations weren’t conscious, but they were there, gently nudging them to make the decision I wanted them to make.

Yes, I’ve just admitted to being a mom who has manipulated her children into making the decisions she wanted them to make. It started out small. (“Try some peas, honey, they are soooo yummy! Just one, pleeeaaaase.”)

As the stakes grew, so did my persuasive skills. And as a former sales manager and trainer, let me tell you, I’ve got some very persuasive skills!

However, I’ll admit I’ve been more successful at guiding my older daughter who, though very independent, likes to please and has always been more open to my manipulation guidance than her sister.  My second born, my adamas, has rarely been more concerned about pleasing me than she has been about following her own gut, and I have a huge amount of respect for that spirit. (Kind of. Sort of. Maybe.)

Last Sunday, as I was driving my younger one, A, home from her confirmation class, we discussed her fast approaching confirmation ceremony. “Oh, so you’ll make your own sashes to wear at the confirmation ceremony?  Have you decided to be confirmed?” I asked. Though resistant to even taking the confirmation class, she agreed when I told her I needed and wanted her to take it for her “Religion” credit for school, but that the final decision to be confirmed was hers. (My husband and I agreed early on that, regardless of giving the girls a foundation in our faith, the decision to join any church or commit to a faith would theirs and theirs alone. Until last Sunday, that is.)

She sat silent in the car. She avoided my question. She pointed out the large Wolfhound being walked along the side of the road. I modified my approach and asked solely about the sash.

She talked a bit about the  symbolism of the sashes before adding that she wasn’t sure she would be joining her 4 classmates on the day of confirmation; she just wasn’t sure she wanted or was ready to be confirmed.

“Really?” I asked, trying to sound casual, ”I guess I’m surprised. Do you really understand what it means to be confirmed?” (She’s bright and not easily played.)

“Yes, Mom, Pastor Greg covered it on Day 1.” I could tell by the tone in her voice battle lines had already been drawn, and experience told me I was not likely to win this war if I waged a “persuasive attack” then-and-there. I tried to change the subject, but my need to push her into the “right decision” was too strong to let it sit.

I approached again, ”Tell me about the sash.”

Her lips closed tighter than brand new Tupperware ® and my hands gripped the steering wheel even tighter. We sat in silence for the next 5 minutes. My thoughts searched for an argument persuasive enough to squelch a teen’s defiance. I had nothing but irrational fears bouncing around my head: What if she never finds a relationship with God? What will her classmates think? What if she never learns to trust God when she feels lonely, sad, or scared? What will Pastor Greg think? What will the other moms think? 

My thoughts were interrupted by her soft spoken admissions, her reasons for being where she was on the “confirmation journey” and I found myself at a loss for words. I had no argument lying in wait to set a trap, nothing ready to jump from my tongue and tell her why her decision was wrong. As we pulled into the driveway, I thanked her for her honesty. Then, I walked silently into the house and straight up the stairs to my bedroom.

As I folded clothes, my thoughts raced again; Why? How do I persuade her? What will __________ think? And then, it hit me. I wasn’t really making this about her or her decision, I was making it about me.

Yes, I want her to feel and experience a loving relationship with God; the kind of relationship I know well but didn’t discover until I was almost 30 and undergoing fertility treatment. And yes, I was concerned about the opinions of others. But, embarrassingly, it was the latter that was driving me to convince her to make the decision I wanted.

I sat down on the bed and grabbed my knotted stomach. I thought about all the times I had pushed her or her sister to make the decision I wanted. I prayed and then, I called her upstairs.

She appeared at the door and before her foot crossed the threshold I was saying familiar words with a new, foreign meaning, “Honey, I’m sorry. It is your decision.”

That was it. No qualifiers. No sales pitch. No threats. No persuasion.

It was, and is, her decision. At almost 16, she has the maturity, the wisdom and, now, the freedom to make this decision, just as her older sister was free to decide where she will attend college.  Do I still hope she’ll choose to be confirmed. In all honesty, yes. But more importantly, I hope she stays authentic to herself.

Now, I’m not, in any way, apologizing for influencing some of the choices my children have made. It’s my job, as a parent, to guide them, to share my experience and wisdom,  and even to set boundaries and house rules that may further direct their decisions. However, it is also my job to gradually release them to make their own decisions, even if/when I disagree with their choice, encouraging them to trust their own voice. (Which is, perhaps, one of the toughest aspects of transitioning to the empty nest years.) And, it’s both my job and joy to celebrate their courage to forge their own paths.

In the last few years, I’ve watched both girls independently make big decisions. Sometimes, they’ve slipped but, more often, they’ve proven they know how to make good decisions and land on their feet. I’ll need to remember that next time I see them heading to church with a stain on their shirt.

Do you allow your children to make their own decisions, even if/when it differs from what you want or think is best?

Posted in Transitional Parenting | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 9 Comments